Menu
Map
The LDS Church encourages reliance on a subjective experience of internal feelings if a person wants to know if the Mormon religion is true. Without a doubt there is a certain attractiveness to the idea that God would provide us with a direct infusion of revelation in a moment of wanting to know the truth about something.
We ask - God answers - we know.
But can we be sure that is how God works in matters of truth? And maybe more importantly, can we trust ourselves to know that the subjective confirmation was really the Holy Spirit? I would venture to guess that most of us can think of times when we thought it was the Spirit—that we were sure Heavenly Father Himself had spoken to our hearts—only to have later circumstances prove otherwise. We are after all imperfect, finite, fallible, even sinful creatures.
So here are some important questions:
Often God provides us with objective facts that corroborate and validate our subjective experiences. For example, God has revealed that He does not lie (Numbers 23:19) and that he does not change (Malachi 3:6), so when we feel confident in God’s power or trustworthiness, or we feel comforted by His promises, those feelings are part of what draws us into closer relationship with God – but while they are subjective feelings they have roots in objective facts. Those same objective facts also help us evaluate feelings of doubt in God’s character, or when we have a sense that God is not trustworthy or that He is distant from us. We can reject those types of subjective feelings and experiences because we know they do not correspond to the objective truth God has already revealed. We should not discount objective truths merely because they call into question our subjective experience. Instead we must subject or feelings and subjective experiences to the test of objective truth.
We cannot and should not let subjective experiences by themselves be our measure for what is true and right. Why? The New Testament warns of the danger of deceiving spirits (1 Timothy 4:1) and instructs us to test the spirits to see if they are from God (1 John 4:1).
Therefore, to pray and ask God if a particular book or writing (like the Book of Mormon) is true or not, and look for this to be confirmed by some sort of feeling or experience or internal sense or “witness”, is to act foolishly, if we have not first looked at the objective evidence and truth that is relevant to the evaluation.
For example, as we’ve seen, God does not lie and he does not change. God has revealed His truth in writings we have already – the Bible.
However, the Book of Mormon fails on each of these points.
This, and other extensively documented objective evidence about the Book of Mormon, allows us to come to conclusions based on facts and objective truth that God has already revealed. Therefore, we can be confident in our decision that the Book of Mormon is not true scripture; it is not from God and should not be looked to for divine guidance.
To ignore all the clear evidence that God has provided and instead simply pray about the Book of Mormon, looking for an unreliable, subjective feeling about it, is an unwise course of action. It disrespects God and what He has already revealed to us, and opens a person up to a being deceived by feelings that have no basis in facts or objective reality.
For further information on a subjective truth test as it relates to Mormonism and the Book of Mormon see the following:
The danger of a subjective truth test
Mormons and the "Burning in the Bosom" (D&C 9:8)
Truth, Salvation and the Mormon Testimony: Does Having a Testimony Make it True?
“Did Not Our Heart Burn within Us?” Luke 24:32 and the Mormon Testimony